Uh yeah...this coming from the same dude that put on OLIVIA?! don't know who Olivia is? - EXACTLY??? I agree that Ciara has moves - but so does Janet Jackson. and like Janet - Ciara is only a PERFORMER - THAT'S IT! SHE HAS NO PIPES AT ALL AND IF THAT'S THE FUTURE OF R&B WHO IN THE HELL WANTS IT?! Beyonce has the vocals, the training and the moves along with other credentials (clothing lines). That is what you call a PACKAGE and that's what ALL of these "entertainers" should WANT to have - not just the ability to "perform." GET A CLUE ON WHAT'S REAL 50!!!!!