Thank you for saying get off Beyonce. She is not the best in the industry. Cici is a true hard worker never lets her fans get bored. Ciara can sing just fine I have heard her live. Just cause she isn't powerhouse doesn't mean she can't sing. If u notice more people who have different kind of voices are getting sign now a days. She probably has a good reason why she is not singing live. Anybody that is a Ciara fan knows she usually sings live.