I'll say there's no one out there who does what Mariah does...sadly there's way too many people doing what Jade does. You wouldn't pick her out of a line-up of a million girls.

She seems a nice enough girl but like Alexandra she just leaves me cold. Both can sing but there's something lacking for me, they're simply not the great singers we keeping told they are. It's just so bland and identikit and I'm really not convinced she has any real charisma.

I don't think her solo career would have been desperately successful and I can see why she sought the security of jumping into an existing successful group. I actually feel a bit sorry for her because I think it may be a decision she comes to regret. She's the new girl walking into a pretty nasty situation.

Whatever kind of bitch Keisha may have been over the years Heidi seemed to get over their initial difficulties- she was still working with her 8 years after joining the group. To collude in pushing her out with someone she's known a lot less time seems disloyal and shady and I can see a lot of fans deserting the group. As someone who'd bought each of their albums I'm really having second thoughts about Sweet 7, an album which, after hearing the original radio version of About A Girl, I was really looking forward to.

I've never really taken to Amelle, still missing Mutya's voice, and now that Keisha's voice has been removed they simply don't sound like the Sugababes anymore. I'm really not sure how long one of the best girl groups of all time is going to be able to stagger on now.