The only time Whitney ever gives a good performance as of late is when she is singing in front of Clive, i.e, Oprah and WMA 2004. Pat, her sister-in-law/manager does not seem to know how to manage Whitney's PR when she is on th road. In Germany, there was a picture of Whitney smoking a cigarette and drinking a glass of red wine. Now, this will not be alarming for any other artist who is about to perform, but for Whitney, it is a PR disaster. She should not be performing under any kind of influence, even though I know it can be a nervous situation. And, smoking cigarettes in public is simply not lady like, nor GOOD FOR HER VOICE. Then returning to the U.S. on a plane, a beautiful and peaceful picture of Whitney was taken by a passenger. However, the story written about the picture was not pretty; another PR disaster. Pat needs to stop being Whitney's relative and learn how to manage her on the road. Yes, even though Whitney is an adult, she has proven that she can act childess, rude and arrogant if no one is there is tap that leg every now and then.