I love the old Whitney, but her new album is boring - the studio vocal ability is still awful by Whitney, there are no HIGH vocals, so it is an effectless album at all.

Despite of this, Mariah's current LP, Memoirs... is a lyrcally, vocally, musically, etc. fantastic and awesome record. I think it is her BEST record yet! And I think her voice is back again.

Mariah's live őerformances are far better than the ones of Whitney.

I respect Whitney because of her power of recovering from drug consumption, but as a musician she is not that big anymore.