Here is the thing. Sam I don't understand how you critique singing when you have on musical back ground. If you think these performance was LIP_SYCHED it further shows your inability to critique music!! You can tell when a person is LIPING it, if you know music you don't have to guess!! Futhermore if you didn't know for sure, which you clearly don't why would you insinuate that it was? Stop hating on this lady and be happy that legends such as Mariah Carey and a few others are still around!!!! Ihave you ever taken time to think this women has been singing for over 20 years now... I mean really singing...... even at her worst she is light years above the majority of artist who are producing music today!!! My advice to you is, enroll in a music fundamental class so you can at least know which notes a singer is singing before you try to criticize what is being song please!!! Because if you don't know that anything you say is void to be who know music!!!!! Cleary by the comments throughout your blog most people are dumb to this fact. Which is fortunate for you!!!!! LOL, keepp using MC to get your ratings up!!!!!