Both performances suck. Honestly, the only one who can actually sing is Jade, just like the only one who could actually sing was Kiesha (and Mutya). Even Siobhan developed an incredible voice after puberty. But Amelle, and ESPECIALLY Heidi are terrible live vocalists. I mean dang...Heidi is TERRIBLE. She and Amelle would get booed off stage if they were unknown women in a talent show. The dance steps are whack as well, but that seems to be a Sugababes staple. You'd think after 11 years and 1,000 lineup changes, somebody somewhere would have taught the girls to dance...I'm just sayin...