Was it as good as Mariah's? No but does it really matter. Alex is not Mariah, she is Alex. She is an alto and so this song is not in her natural range yet she still did a great job with it. She made it fun and added her own little spin on it. Alex has her does her own thing. And who cares if mariah can't sing it as well as she did in 1994. She did it once and that's enough. There is no singer alive who can touch what Mariah did in the 90's with that VOICE. She is still the greatest.