Obviously lots of people have a lot of hope & love for Whitney and are wishful hearing. It's not hate, it's honesty--her voice is all but gone. "Tip top shape"? That's just a flat out lie unless you're love for Whitney has caused you to completely lose your hearing. She talks her way through most songs and takes unnaturally long breaks between some notes and she doesn't make it worth the wait or build up. She still has a great tone that she can use to her advantage during parts of a song for a nice burst here and there but she can barely hold notes and at points sounds really bad when she tries. Overall, I'm not sure she's improving and it just may get worse with the extra strain she has to use to try to be the old Whitney. It's just hard to watch for someone like me who really appreciates her body of work and what use to be the "voice."