@CRAVER & OTHERS ALIKE : some of you people forget mariah writes, produces, arranges & sings ALL her own music. She came into the game writing & co-writing her own music and still does, the only songs she has not written on her own are covers. Aside from the lackluster sales of "Memoirs", the album garnered some of her best reviews in the last decade, a lot of critics compared it to the masterpiece that was "Butterfly", thats a feat in its own. Mariah didn't need to sell 5 million copies for the album to be a success. Mariah's voice is still in tact, & she can still sing circles around ya faves. she is still belting out emotions when she was on tour, have you heard 100% ?, once again her voice is showcased, I wanna know what love is live, epic. listen to the whole "Memoirs" album, then tell me she cant sing.