@Sarah:

Why not? i'm not delusional, Whitney has suffered vocal damange,t hat's not a secret. However, she still has an instrument left and with good health, some vocal rehab and consistency and breath support as she suffers from bronchitis (true), she will be fine.

My issue with Mariah is that she has been lipping for years and it's deceitful. There is no reason for her to lip so much. It's like lying. I know her vocals are damaged from nodules and alcohol, however, nothing wrong with a little lipping for some of the bridges of 1 or 2 songs but she lipped parts in just about every song.

That is unacceptable. I'm not going to slag her off too much for the cut notes and the breathlessness but I can't give her a pass for all that lipping. That is just bad!

Having said that, I still wish her well. I can critique her 'job', her 'vocals' without being mean to the person or calling her out of her name