I don't think that TreyC had a chance of winning but that's really not the point. Katie has been in the bottom two, three times and each time she's escaped. I get that Cheryl was conflicted and wanted to send it to deadlock but why did Simon and Louis vote for Katie? She didn't even complete her song, forgot the lyrics, and said "sod it" and sat down and begged the judges for another chance. On what planet should she have continued? No, TreyC would not have won but she deserved better treatment than she received from the X Factor. And anyone who watches the show knows that the only act Cheryl really cares about is Cher and if she had been in the bottom with Katie, Cheryl would have made a choice.