I think its funny how some these idiots deemed Mariah a flop because of the sales of her christmas album. You idiots, its not like its an actual album. For a christmas album and considering the lack of people who buy music these days (especially christmas music) , she is doing pretty damn good. For you info, EMC2 went platinum and memoirs went gold! In today's world thats pretty damn good. You got people like C error that cant sell over 30 k now and days. Also, do you think Mariah really gives a damn about her sales for this album? Please! Homegirl is PAID. She releasing albums for fun! She has nothing to prove to all these other chick thats are out now. She has been there and done that. So you beyonce stans or whoever need to stop coming for Mariah. Yall always hating!