If you have to defend someones vocal ability, then hands down that person is not a singer. I cant stomach her voice. Im sorry shes beautiful, can dance, but it erks me that she has gotten by with her doubed vocals. Remember, Christina Millian and Ashanti complained about the label overlapping their thin vocals just to make JLO sound decent in Play and her singles with Jarule.. that woman has no right judging a singing competition...how can you tell someone how to sing when you dont even have a lick or real singing ability.. sure she can carry a tune and has a strong head voice..but it sounds awful..I cant...God bless her for her drive though..b/c thats what she has to succeed...she is not a singer and never will be