She was flat at times, but she has a great voice! I like how Melanie is so passionate about her craft and articulate when she speaks. The only reason why people don't care about her is because she's not selling her ass. You guys are ridiculous, I swear. Melanie can be a big star making urban music if she was promoted right. I don't know what's with these urban R&B musicians now-a-days. Back in the day, Brandy, Monica, SWV, TLC, Brian McKnight, Dru Hill were all selling millions and millions worldwide with every one of their albums and had great promotion and management. Why can’t real R&B singers of today find the right people?