all these fans need realise that skelly has NO QUALIFICATIONS to be a JUDGE to anybody. She has had ZERO solo succsess, yes that Nelly i luv u mess, (what happenedd to the part two, yeah it was "gone"), Ms Kelly went solid pine and wood and this new album has one hit / 5 singles. Please sit!!!

Atleast Cheryl. like Simon, when he started Idol, is unknown, and has had succsess in the UK (WHen did Skelly have a solo no.1 in the UK, oh maybe in 2002 or 3), Cheryl can ENTERTAIN, she sure cant sing, and has limited talent, but shes fesh and new and damn near better than a washe up pussy cat doll who serves up little more than a shake of her vagina and no-booty to the camera only to have a no.97 song on the billboard charts. P.S The Rihanna-formula faux-jamaican twang is a mess!! sit!!