The thing is that they're just not interesting anymore. This was one group that people really identified with and thats why i feel the reaction is so bad. I think the difference with Heidi and Amel is that they replaced members instead of members being thrown out, and with Amel they picked her because she was the closest thing they could find that sounded like Mutya. I dont think that Jade fits in, she fits in as much a Michelle does in destiny's child which vocally isn't very well