to know that a person is singing live u can hear them breath And if they don't mean they are not singing live. Hater beyonce & lady gaga are rarely singing live I saw lady gaga singing live once, what a catastrophe & beyonce singing in jimmy the other day it is not live at all. So praise a singer when they sing live. Kelly Rowland did a nice job singing & dancing. Woah. Hater fall back & praise.