This wasn't that bad at all, and I notice TGJ didn't bother to publish the footage of her doing Redemption Song at the same place, and that was actually pretty good. They really are flogging a dead horse here, Rihanna fans aren't deaf and the shade is getting old. If she worked on her vocals more, lazy cow that she is, she could be an adequate live singer. She is fine in her comfort range but struggles with both high and low notes, she needs to find her own way of singing when she is performing live.