Their BOTH great! Like you said, either can be credible winners. However, everytime I watch Joshua's performance I feel like saying Amen. I think he would KILL Sunday's best! I have my vote on Jessica for American Idol. She has so much control. My only problem with her is she studies Beyonce to the Tee. That can harm her. Both great artist, and no matter who wins, I'l be content. GREAT season of Idol.