Better her than Kelly, she is a better live singer and dancer, Kelly was pretty dire last series - although I do give her props for singing live rather than miming like Cheryl Cole. I'd rather her than Cheryl, Tulisia and Kelly - although I'd really like to see Dannii back who was the only decent judge on the panel, not much chance of that now Simon has kissed and told, slimebag that he is. Kelly was not right for the UK, too much gushing and weeping and wailing, its not our bag at all - the jury is out on Nicole, will have to wait and see ;o)