Dude i would be so scared if aretha was a judge cause shes a LEGENED and if she says no to me then i would have to go crawl under some rock. Aretha was named the rolling stones BEST SINGER, so imagine auditioning infront of her!?

I think beyonce, youtube her when she was in x factor austrailia she was great and gave great advice. But at the same time i dont want her to do it cause i want her to do another album and world tour and be great like the I Am world tour!!

DUDE ALICIA KEYS WOULD BE AWSOME!!

Not Mariah though shes a queen she dosent need american idol.

AND THIS TIME AMERICAN IDOL PLEASE A JUDGE THAT CAN SING BETTER THAN THE CONSTANTS CAUSE I BET YOUR ASS LAST SEASONS CONSTANTS SANG BETTER THAN JLO.