In reply to King B>Rihanna.

I know that the Immaculate is a GH, that's why I said it was a compilations, but for someone like Madonna who was high profile celebrity/artist in the early 90s to sell 2 mil in the U.S. and 6 mil ww is not great at all. That doesn't really matter though, because "Erotica" was her best album imo and the only reason it flopped was because it was so controversial, risky, and out of the box, much like American Life, etc. At the end of the day Madonna didn't care to appease the commercial success formula and made a masterpiece instead.