Lol ppl are still talking about this. Listen bitches regardless of whether beyonce didn't sing 100% live she sang over a prerecorded track. Just becuz someone lips doesn't mean they can't still sing. Cuz if that was true Mariah, Whitney and Celine would not even be placed that high on a pedestal. And there has been controversy with them lipping also. Beyonce didn't rehearse with the band and since she's a perfectionist she will not chance screwing up the national anthem and being disrespectful unlike screamtina aguilera. The navy is still pressed over this becuz they know bey will sing circles around their weak fave any day. LOL. Seethe.