To be comparing a newbie to a legend like Mariah says a lot so negative comments or positive, she must be doin somethin right. Also you are comparing her to ppl who have been in the game for years when this is her mainstream DEBUT so she hasn't even grown yet or found herself. So for her to be on the level she already is on says a lot too. This is the first single, so we don't even know how the rest of her music will sound. & she's just getting use to the stage so instead of tearing her down so fast, see what happens first. even legends like Mariah & Whitney had to learn before they owned the stage in every way.