In reply to CzarM.

Please. Mariah has had off moments even at her prime. She has been singing with nodules her entire career. Her live vocals in 2001-2005 can run circles around her vocals from 1999. Go listen to performances like Vision Of Love Zurich 2003. Joy To The World 2004, With You I'm Born Again 2005 for example. And tell me that those aren't great vocals. And this comment from will i am is from 2013. When Marah did an Australia tour and delivered very good vocals including acapella moments.