In reply to Mark111.

I agree. LOL these comments about them are hilarious to me because it reminds me of stories about people like Billie Holiday or really old hollywood. Those that paved the way for singers with a unique style and voice got criticized really bad because no understood where they were coming from. Billie use to get criticized all the time due to her raspy tone just like Alicia. They would go Billie you can't sing your voice is too raspy you off key LOL., but due to her conveying raw emotion and depth made her one of the greatest jazz/blues singers in history. Marvin Gaye was different to he had a high pitch voice but once he touch that stage Mother mother the crowd went wild. I can't see these to are overrated their fame was well earned and they are both extremely talented. They have their own style and sound when it comes to singing. Alicia more jazzy soulful velvety and JT more pop/soulful.They will be remembered for a longtime time.