Hmmm... Are you fucking serious now???????? This much photoshop is used for EVERY celebrity, especially that age. That Celine photo you gave as an example: do you think it isn´t retouched??????? In Mariah´s case is more the weight (although when she loses it she looks gorgeous, like last year for #beautiful for example) and in Celine´s case it is the face, colour,etc. In Madonna´s case her face and arms, etc. You are obsessed with Mariah!