She doesn't sound so bad, she's been tru a lot, at least she sings live, if we compare to Britney Spears, JLo, and some others that CAN'T sing a note live, and people won't critize or put down, why they do to Mariah!!!!! Bunch of haters, l love Mariah, im a true fan, she always be the best!!!!!! Fuck what people think about her