First let me say that Ciara has blossomed into a beautiful woman. She stunningly gorgeous damn! Now onto those vocals...no, just no. She started off flat and continued into a rollercoaster of sharp notes and pitchiness. I'm not one who believes that you have to holler and hit whistle notes on every song in order to be a great vocalist, but this performance just wasn't it. While her vocals have improved since she debuted, she could use a lot of work. Good luck Cici.