Lol y'all hating have no facts. She's selling out arenas in Europe, she's dating a billionaire that buys her millions of dollars worth of presents, she's charting her Christmas bonus track as always which when will your faves? She's actually singing amazingly this year there are videos that prove this. You call her fat, yet she's lost weight and is human and can fluctuate. You call her a flop, um meanwhile you guys work 9-5 jobs and she sits pretty on her hundreds of millions and the fact that she's Mariah Carey a voice that inspired and birthed your faves. Aaa and she is oblivious to your existence meanwhile you're fuming on about her and stay sad being pressed. Learn to love yourself before throwing all this pointless shade. Y'all sad.