TEOM is right up there with Tina Turner's Private Dancer as one of the greatest musical comebacks of all time! I think this was when she really solidified her legendary status because even though her career took a hit with the Glitter album, she was still viewed her as an icon because her artistry was starting to influence a generation of singers that came after her. This album recaptured Mariah's old fans and also brilliantly introduced her to new ones. 2005 - 2006 were truly the last big years for R&B on the charts because Mary J. Blige would experience a career resurgence with The Breakthrough album a year after Mimi. The performance with John Legend is one of my personal favorites because she interpreted the song beautifully. However, the Grammy performance is where it's at. Like Sam said, it wasn't flawless but it was her display of strength that made for a powerful showing.