In reply to maurice.

ok ok, let me tell you the deal.
Kelly actually said they had a joint bday party -- Beyonce's cousin celebrated with Ciara -- I don't know if they are friends or whatever.
Secondly, that pic of Ciara and Beyonce posing for a pic if PHOTOSHOPPED.
Beyonce did not take one picture with Ciara. Not one. I believe it was on the Breakfast Club where Kelly Rowland stated that it was a joint birthday party.