Basically Melanie ain't down if it ain't all 5 and that's totally fair enough as a 5 piece the Spice Girls make history and that's that! However, Mel B, Geri and Emma have every right to continue working with each other if they want to, Calling themselves Spice Girls - GEM is a nice way of showing that they are a portion of the group that still wanna make music together and tour together and if so why not? Bell Biv Devoe did it outside of New Edition, Dumblonde have done it outside of Danity Kane. I don't think Spice - GEM are trying to top what they've done in the past I just think they really wanna celebrate there 20th and are dying to make some new music and share there hits with there fans. Me personally I'm glad it's 3 and not 4 cos otherwise the5th who dropped out would got all the stick of fans. I totally respect Mel and Victorias decisions but I'm also looking forward to seeing what the other 3 have to offer, The Spice Girls are fun!