Toxic was recorded a good 15 years ago. This post is irrelevant in 2017 because it is not really what her voice sounded like 15 years that matters. It is what condition is her voice today? This is an average carry-a-tune type singer that damaged her thin vocals by smoking and her lifestyle. Now she is lip-synching to studio recording recorded 15 to 20 years ago instead of re-recording newer vocals to lip-synch to. The comparisons to Janet and Madonna are irrelevant as well because both Janet and Madonna do NOT use 15 to 20 year old vocals to lip-synch to. They re-recorded their music and keep their carry-a-tune vocals in better shape (Madonna is a health nut and Janet does NOT smoke).