This was great for her first show. She looks amazing! Also, it's not so much about the voice being permanently damaged. It's just that she doesn't rehearse or warm up. That's the main thing. The warming up would make her a thousand times greater. She is still super great of course. But that would do wonders. She was more engaging & moved around some. It's a few haters just doing what they do best hating.. But she is great. This was quite good for a first show & her getting over whatever..