Were some of you sleeping under a rock or something? Sales are practically dead for at least 10 years, and prior to that, in the late 2000s, with exception to digital singles, they were pretty low. How did you expect Beyoncé to sell tens of millions albums in the US? It's all about streams today, and Beyoncé is holding up very well. She has 37 million monthly listeners, which is fantastic for someone who started a career in the 1990s.