In reply to Ms. Ling Ling.

First of all, she's actually selling more in her first week by approximately 15,000 more than Caution. Lastly, most artists aren't even selling these days because nobody is hardly buying physical copies anymore and it takes 1500 streams of just one song to equal an album equivalent. Ed Sheeran only sold 6000 more than Mariah's first week estimate. Nobody in their 50s is going to sell like they did in their 20s. Mariah is a LEGACY artist and should be appreciated for who she is and accomplished in her career (Hello, 19 #1s and more than any solo artist in history)!!!!!!!!!