“Madonna and I are very different…”
While she is best known for her theatrical and (at times) over the top stage shows and music videos, Queen of Pop Madonna has seen her name line the credits of multiple multiplatinum albums as a contributing songwriter over her 30+ year career. Recently nominated for induction to the 2017 Songwriters Hall of Fame, the Grammy winner’s live stage shows have seen her play drums, bass guitar, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, and even a ukelele over that same three decade period.
For the previously mentioned reasons and more fans of the iconic pop star were none-too-pleased with Lady Gaga after the ‘Bad Romance’ beauty’s bad choice of words in a recent interview seemed to imply the Material Girl doesn’t write her own material:
Madonna and I are very different. Just saying. I wouldn’t make that comparison at all and I don’t mean to disrespect Madonna. She’s a nice lady and she’s had a fantastic huge career. She’s the biggest pop star of all time, but I play a lot of instruments. I write all my own music. I spend hours and hours a day in the studio. I’m a producer. I’m a writer. What I do is different.
Needless to say, the quote did not fall on deaf ears. In fact, if the Twitter response is anything to judge by, the 30-year-old singer may have reignited the beef between herself and her nearly 60-year-old counterpart:
Lady Gaga said she’s different than Madonna because she writes, plays instruments, produces her music… Madonna doesn’t? pic.twitter.com/XsUK8bMRVJ
— FEIM (@FeimM) October 20, 2016
Click here to watch Gaga’s full interview.
gaga is so dumb for going after a legend
ÕLDONNA IS NOT A LEGEND AND NEVER WILL BE ONE. SHE HAS NO TALENT, THAT’S THE MAIN QUALITY REQUIRED FOR A LEGEND.
Dude you’re point of view has Bo basis on the actual facts.. Gaga is not young anymore either. Madonna has more talent than you or Gaga could ever dream of
Really? So because YOU think someone has no talent that means they aren’t a legend? After selling 300 million albums and singles, 38 top ten hits, sold out tours, paved the way for all the current female artists, fashion icon, etc, she’s not a legend?? You really are some special kind of stupid.
Madonna is a disgusting p**.
Instead of backlashing madonna
U need to learn a thing or two from her
LoOK in the mirror
Promising Hilary supporters free blowjobs??
Straight up N A S T Y
Gaga is doing this to give joann some attention
Truth.
where are the lies?
OLDONNA SUCKS!!!!! SHE HAS ZERO TALENT!!!! CELINE DION OUTLASTED THAT OLD, TALENTLESS, TONE DEAF H**, THAT’S WHY HER ALBUM IS SELLING MORE THAN FLOP HEART~~~~~~
She’s trash and an embarrassment to music.
#Blowjobsforhilary
I want to say theat rebel heart is an amazing era after of 33 years of the most succesfull carreer, Madonna earns this year 1 award like musical icon by people choice awars, woman of the year by billboard, nomination for sonwriter fame of fame and many more, her last tour surrpass the flop tour of lady garbage artraveflop tour, art pop is other copy and flop album, the firts album of Madonna, Madonna 10 millions, like a virgin 22 millions, true bleu 25 millions and like a prayer 15 millions (firts year) lady garbage red and blue she was fired, the fame 12 millions, Btway 5.2 millions, artflop 1.9 millions, s*** to s*** 1 millions and now joan is a future flop…MADONNA IS SO TALENT
Hardly shade she just pointed out some of their differences. This whole let’s hate on gaga for any and everything is getting a bit pathetic tbh
Exactly. It´s appalling and it got pathetic like years ago already.
Getting pissed
Let me log out before I really drag someone today.
Madonna wasn’t a fad who went from the biggest artist in the world to a niche that only white gays are checking for in only 2 eras.
It doesn’t matter if you literally write, produce, play every instrument on the damn album, none of that matters when the music itself SUCKS. It’s bitter f** stans stay dragging Lemonade but it’s Metacritic score will be at least 30 points higher than Toucanne, kii. Toucanne probably won’t even get Anti’s score.
B**** stfu already before John drags tf out of your Rosie O’Donnell looking ass.
Clinging to John’s bible length essays now ?
I get you SO bothered. Dead at you bringing up Lana for absolutely no reason, you better pray to god HDD has Toucanne selling more than Honeymoon on Saturday.
Lmao you’re scared of john you p**** he stays putting you in your place like the pathetic tramp you are.
He’s only playing himself since he’s the only one reading those Atlas Shrugged-length essays of excuses, death.
GAGA IS MORE TALENTED THAN LLAMA AND FLOPSEY, SHE OUTDID THEIR CAREERS WITH ONE ALBUM.
No one even mentions Lana’s wack ass she’s irrelevant and has been dragged so bad on this site. Rosie take your L .
lady garbage is a good song writer, so good with the piano, bad dancer, wrong act, verygood imitator and flop
Antis scores should of been higher, critics literally didn’t like it cause it didn’t have any “hits”
–
Anyway speaking of Madonna, yes the only reason her sales declined in the 90s was because of the whole Erotica era and it was over the top and back then the world wasn’t as open to stuff like that but even that album manage to sell 5m and its ranked as one of her best. Madonna was able to comeback by cleaning up her image by presenting herself as “normal” with Bedtime Stories and Ray of Light, something Gaga is trying to do her but again unlike Madonna is failing because it seems forced.
@Skyfall stop trying to Rihanna happen, she’s NOT gonna happen
I think Anti will end up making year-end critics lists, which are more important anyways.
I think it’s her best album, even though it falls off at the end. The first Rih album I got through entirely since Rated R.
What a dumb excuse. Most of the most critically acclaimed albums don’t have “hits”, that including Lemonade according to the Navy. Anti belongs nowhere near above a C, which is exactly what it got. Travis Scott named the album for one. And it was named that because she didn’t have a narrative for the album. Never mind the fact that the album is ridiculously overproduced, so much so that the producers’ names belong on the front of the album and not the back. Critics didn’t not like the album because it didn’t have any hits, they didn’t like the album because the album was made without any rhyme or reason heading in no real direction. If you didn’t notice, Rihanna has a tendency to half-ass things.
Hence the reviews,
“The ultimate impression the album leaves isn’t just that of an artist who failed to follow through on her vision, but who never bothered to conceive one in the first place”
“Anti is a chaotic and scattershot album, not the product of a committed artistic vision, or even an appealingly freeform aesthetic, but rather an amalgam of approaches, tones, styles and moods.”
“a succession of half-baked ideas rather than a cohesive album”
“If only more of these songs could actually carry the weight of Rihanna’s bid for freedom–a bid that is, ultimately, half-baked.”
Spill the truth serum into my flask! The monster’s are shook and scattering for cover!
The way the hive got shook when Thothanna went number 1 on billboard 200 twice when will kooolaid?
@RectumPuss LMAO! Still trying to hide behind fRih when her very stans are dragging Fad lol! The decline and blow to the monster’s self confidence is real! Stand by your fav hoeee! We ain’t talking about fRih!
Toucanne will be lucky to go #1 though with Michael Buble releasing the same day, that’s the kii. All he has to do is perform on Ellen or something and Fad’s chances are gone.
@Rosie DEATH not Michael Buble waking from his year long slumber to release his annual Christmas corals being a threat to the “Almighty Fadga”!! ???
Right ⚰
And hes huge in the UK too. Fad has almost no chance of #1 there.
Rosie shut your FATASS UP.
Where’s those pics you have?
You disappeared last night when I asked for proof.
Ridiculous comment not even worth correcting
Rosie
You´re PATHETIC! The hate you have for Gaga is not normal. You stay trying to recollect stats as if it was your job, stats that are not related to the topic. Your comment you just worte is invalid since Gaga herself said in this interview Madonna is the most successful artist ever. So??? What´s your point? Hater? LMAO Which “monsters” are dragging Lemonade?????????? Stop inventing things. Are you mistaking them with Rihanna fans??? Cause as far as I know those two stan bases are the ones constatly dragging each other. You find any excuse to hate on Gaga on personal levels. You need a happier life asap. It´s funny you never talk about Lana´s NOvoice (love her as you know, cause I´m not a hater) or where were you when Madonna HERSELF said the blowjob thing? (I´m mentioning that cause you and a few others, as pathetic haters, have been using what a couple of Gaga fans said years ago somewhere about blowjobs as an argument to hate on Gaga LOL, but you don´t say anything if Madonna says it HERSELF). Seriously, give it up, gaga didn´t even really shade.
Shut up hypocrite! You always say the same s*** about Rihanna, you are the last one with credibility here. Don’t you stalk every post of hers shading how she is untalented, a weak album seller, how she relies on features, about 3 buzz singles (your beloved Mariah did that too but that was what I call failing miserably since she failed to chart at all, not what Rihanna did), how she had to re-record her album from start (even though that’s a lie since most of Anti songs were already posted by her as snippets on Instagram almost a year before the album release)? And Rosie herslef is a Beyonce fan, so are HailLegendBeysus, RihNavy and many others yet Rihanna fans are dragging Gaga? Gaga deserves all of that, her fans were laughing at all pop stars when Gaga was at her peak (and ironically her peak was all about generic dance music and weird costumes). Rihanna has been bigger than Gaga since 2011 (Loud and Born This Way sold the same amount of albums even though the other one had the biggest promo ever and 400k were purchased for $0.99, Unapologetic outdid Artpop). Monsters called Beyonce a flop during 4 era and said how Telephone was her last big hit, yet Beyonce surpassed her in 2013 as well. So both stanbases deserves to drag her
No what’s PATHETIC is these long ass books you keep putting in my reply box every time I comment.
Fadga gets dragged by damn near everybody on this site except for Rima and LOL so death at you singling me out, tf. Also at you completely ignoring the fact that both of them stay dragging Beyonce whenever possible ?
And ok at those passive aggressive wannabe drags in here, like coming for Lana’s voice even though she sounds nearly exactly like the studio version in 2016. But totally “not a hater! unlike you rosie ;)”
I´m very proud to say I ABSOLUTELY never act like that with Rihanna or any other, not waht Rosie does. I only talk about talent and music. I never hate these people on personal levels. And also believe me, i don´t download or buy or am waiting for any Rihanna update on itunes and things like that. I´m not a hater like Rosie. End of story. You people not being able to see the difference is appalling. Didn´t you learn simple logic at school?
Madonna mainly writes, composes, and produce all her songs, she plays Piano and Guitar too from what I’ve seen so the “shade” was tired. What’s the point of bragging about writing your own songs if they’re boring and trash. Madonna was still releasing bops in the 90s and 2000s and 2010s. Gaga a music became dull and redundant although I don’t think Artpop is as bad as some try to make it.
Artpop was her last decent attempt since the Fame Monster tbh
Well she has to get johnathan to sell some type of way.
Anti sold 469 in a week the navy can’t talk.
She will not outsell anti as a whole lol
Drag ha!
Omg she’s always beefing with Madonna during a new era.
H** HUSH!!!!! REVIVAL HAS YET TO CRACK 1 MILLION WORLDWIDE.
@Molly, keep that dicccksucker closed till your favs learn how to SELL
Fad will do anything for publicity! The bitxh has gone as far as letting someone puke on her! SMH!
H** HUSH!!!! BLEACHONCE IS THE MOST DESPERATE, ATTENTION SEEEKING H** IN THE INDUSTRY.
@HailLegendSUS, it was “ART” according to her ? And her Artpop could mean anything ? Kiiii
Twitter is a mess today. First the hive going in on Kanye Kardashian now the grandkids vs the little morons???
Twitter is useless.
This whole feud is tired, I’m not falling for it but she saw it coming, what she said comes as shady, because don’t tell me that someone who has followed almost every move of Madonna’s career as Gaga has done since day one, couldn’t know that Madonna writes, co-writes, produces and co-produces her songs, she indeed implied that Madonna doesn’t do any of that.
SHE IS RIGHT THOUGH. OLDONNA CAN’T SING TO SAVE HER LIFE! WITHOUT CO-WRITERS, SHE CAN’T WRITE SONGS. SHE HAS 0 RAW TALENT. OLDONNA IS ALL SMOKE AND MIRRORS. WITHOUT BIG PRODUCTION ON STAGE SHE IS NOTHING. HER MUSIC IS TRASH, SHE’S BEEN STRUGGLING FOR OVER 30 YEARS TO MAKE AT LEAST ONE GOOD SONG AND SHE HAS YET TO DO IT.
@JK Rima, give it up bítch!!
@Suicidie, when you’re on, you’re ON!
Hi s******! I´m glad you are over this feud our admired Madonna started when she needed the promo for the Superbowl. And yes I agree Gaga must have seen this coming when as she was saying the words, but somehow after being asked she just said it without thinking too much. We all do it sometimes and are regretting it at the same time we are speaking the words. That´s my bet 🙂
KIIIIII, I don’t really even use RIMA like that but Roseanne’s fat greasy ass and my fav HailLEGENDsus is draggingggg HA!
Sigh .. that’s it I’m done with her. I’ve tried to stand by her but she keeps saying and doing stuff that makes it hard.
I’m no longer a little monster from this moment on.
I became a fan the moment I watched Just Dance in 2008 back when Mtv played videos now it’s 2016 and I’m about to watch her career end.
It’s been good mother monster will not forget the music, memories and giving me a chance to loose my virginity to a guy I met at the born this way ball
Your life is truly an embarrassment. F****g
U was never a Virgin.. U were born f*****
What the hell? LMAO You are obviously not a fan and yes your life is an embarrassment if you live it through what these people you don´t know personally say at a particular moment. You never were here for the music. That´s for sure.
Rosie sis, no one on this site even claims you anymore and Matthew is always private messaging me on Tumblr about how hard you try to play this “aesthetic” of coolness when you’re just a flop.
I’ll be leaking your user profile soon
YOU ARE MORE DESPERATE THAN ROSIE BLEACHONCE FAN HIDING UNDER RIHANNA NAVY!
EXPOSE her pls I can’t stand her ass. She thinks she’s better than everyone because she listens to irrelevant indie bands and artists that make no impact on the charts and in general
Legends Panel is gonna be litty
Yas!!! Legends panel is going to scalp Fad for reals! (In my Legends Panel Prince voice) I LIVEEEEE FOR THE KI KI’S!!! ???
Whop….there goes her album sales ;( #poorstephanie
RIHNAVY IS A M***** LOOKING FLOP ASS BLEACHONCE FAN FROM THE HOOD.STOP HIDING BEHIND RIHANNA YOU LIFELESS TRASH.
Screaming at this RihNavy thing threatening to leak a tumblr out of all things
B****, what tumblr? I haven’t been on there since 2013. Only people left on there now are wannabe activists.
And where are those pics. I don’t see them still. Probably some s*** you stole from Google Images.
Madonna may casually know how “play” a few chords on some instruments but she doesn’t really play those instruments like a true musician nor write like a true writer, so I get what she’s saying.. but she should have left that out she knew it would be taken as shade. I’m not clear why
WTF is this s***? “doesnt write like a true writer”?
have you seen the lyrics of her ray of light, erotica, and Music albums? even the new ones? she has literal poetry about her self empowerment and her mother and daughter
what does gaga do? sing ra ra ra oelala judaaa judaaa? that’s real songwriting?
Girl madonna didn´t do Ray of Light alone. It sounded so different and had way more quality than what she had been putting out before because she worked with different and very creative people, not because she did that herself like it was nothing. I love those albums and admire Madonna so it´s not shade AT ALL. But your point just felt flat.
Did she lie? Gays will take anything as a Diss. Granny is not talented, she’s controversial.
We all know Madonna play instruments, write and produce… and we all know that Gaga do too.
But Gaga was wrong by trying to say she is more an artist than Madge… in fact Gaga wanted to say she sing better and fail to find the wise words.
But Gaga is not really that “songwriter” is not because you write some material that it means it’s good… Gaga have so many dumb lyrics in her songs.
Being an artist it’s a broad term, what’s matter it’s to share and express a vision to the world…Rihanna and Bey just change word in the lyrics but that don’t mean their are less artist…the important is they succeed to share their world with us… btw we have seen Rihanna playing drums and guitar in her tour and seen Beyoncé playing piano in Die and Lemonade but that does not mean they are good at it…
Is not because you Gaga play many instruments that imply you are good at it…
As I see all this flopage did not open her eyes and put down on earth she is still arrogant remember she said Born this way would be the album of the millenium then said artpop will change the music industry …girl when will you learn ?
Look someone like Lady Gaga is so much more talented than Rihanna, even if what she does works for maintaining a career so far or not. Get over it and enjoy them for what they are.
Ofcourse, this is expected from her, shes got a new album out in 24hrs…. why not rehash old drama with the original copy.
In other words, I am the pivotal of an artist and as for Madonna , you do the maths. Double ouch??????
Im going to need @LOL and @Rima b********* to stop trolling. Nobody is here for you useless low-life bítches and your wannabe artsy-fartsy ass fave.
I see nothing wrong with this. Madonna’s a salty b1tch that Gaga has emulated throughout her first two eras. Ready for her to fully embrace the fact that she’s actually got a voice, is musically gifted, and is worth listening to.
Problem here is not that Madonna is a salty bish either. This was once again created by media, social media and stans. That´s all. AlthoughIi agree that Madonna is salty when she feels a newbie is more talented than her or could get too much success. Same way my beloved Mariah is probably salty about those type of situations too 🙂
Rima, johnvidal and LOL have been doing too much these past few months. Hope you guys used beyonces stylist to fasten down your edges because the dragging yall deserve..
I´m nothing like those two sorry. I only relied to real haters who are waiting to hate on personal levels. That´s all. I defend talent. If I have to defend Beyonce I do it despite not being a fan, and her fans know that too. Same with Xtina if I have to, same with Madonna if I have to. And so on. Despite none of them being my real favorites.
We love everybody Gaga! Madonna isn’t a singer but you can’t deny her influence and involvement in her music dahhling!
Exactly Mariah! LMAO She praised her though.
She did not imply that Madonna does not write. unlike Madonna, gaga has a writing credit on every single song in her discography. Madonna has plenty of writing credits, but she can’t say that. However, Madonna has had a much longer career & has had more opportunity for collaborations.
lol it’s the other way around. madonna has a lot more solo writing credits while gaga has a lot of co writers
she also says she produced “venus” herself but then it turned out she used samples and it had five producers and songwriter
Silly women, Madonna’s one of the most well respected songwriters in the music industry, I remember her saying that when she moved to New York, the first thing she did when she finally had some money was buy a keyboard so she could write songs.. On top of that if you know Madonna’s history she started out as Drummer in a band called The Breakfast Club before she made them get rid of the lead singer so she could be the lead lol! Gaga rips of Madonnas music as well as her image and she wants to mention songwriting, b**** have an original idea and then have A seat At The Table x
Marketing plot
LOl I knew this would happen when I left one of the first comments on a previous post about this last night. It´s seriously retarded and predictable. I suppose if I go back to that post or read this entire one everybody will be doing the most. Gaga as many others is constantly asked about issues that they don´t want to answer. It´s the interviewers fault and then obviously the stans. It gets old. People need a life. I love Madonna for what she is and also the great artist that Lady Gaga is. That´s all.
major overreaction but I get it… Whoresie and ’em crazy haters need something to m********* to before they seethe over Joanne’s performance.
major overreaction but I get it… Whòresie and ’em crazy haters need something to m********* to before they seethe over Joanne’s performance.
LOL Rosie listened to the album days ago before people who like Gaga (truth is she loves her but hates her, that person has a problem). She´s a true real fan. She probably masturbates when she listens to the album several times throughout the day 🙂
side-note: I wonder why TGJ never flags comments calling Rihanna names or using xenophobic and racial slurs yet whenever I call one of these girls for who she is it flags me… stop playing favorites
Whether Modanna writes, or is talented or not Idk I have never studied her I’m not really a fan, Lady Gaga has based alot of her career paying homage to Madonna. And I always find it very funny how artist do something controversial right before an album drops. Thsee artist are no better than reality TV stars.
LADYSHIT, SEARCHING PUBLICITY HER NEW SINGLES ARE FLOPS, EVEN IN VEVO SHE IS A FLOP NOW, HER LAS 2 ALBUMS AND LAST TOUR ..FLOPS, SHE IS A SONGWRITER BUT NOT THE BEST, SHE IS A GOOD SINGER BUT NOT THE BEST, SHE IS A BAD DANCER, BAD ACT, BAD GUITAR PLAYER, SHE IS A SMALL S***, LOOKS OLDER AND SICK, HSE FEELS JELOUS AND ENVY…..HER LAST 2 ALBUMS ONLY 3 MILLIONS, SHE BUY AWARDS….SHE IS THE BIGGEST IMITATOR OF MADONNA THE FICKING LEGEND, THE F****** QUEEN OF MUSIC..gagashit
MADONNA IS SO TALENT,
SINGER
ELECTRIC GUITAR PLAYER FROM EARLY YEARS,
DANCER,
PLAY BASS
PLAY DRUMS
ACOUSTIC GUITAR PLAYER
PLAY THE UKULELE
SHE CAN ACT
FASHION DESIGNER
DIRECTOR OF FILMS
SONGWRITER
WRITER
FILANTROPICS
MODEL
SHE SINGING IN MANY GENRES MORE THAN OTHERS
Wow
Gaga is beyond delusional madonna has 4 decades of the most iconic career based on her talents of playing drums to guitar to her song writing ability and always being ahead of her time yes Madonna herself has said she’s not the best singer in the world but sorry best voices in the world are boring plus you have seen evita her vocals are awesome and at least she sings live
If Gaga is different from her why is she following madonnas era’s in her albums sorry but madonna did the cowboy theme 16 years ago on her music album dare we say more wearing the cowboy hats and bedazzled studded jackets next Gaga will do the ray of light theme or disco album confessions no words for Gaga she will never ever ever did I mention ever have a career span like madonna
And another thing lady copy and paste has. Tilt her entire fake career copying and referencing madonna!!!!!
Gaga always needs to talk about madonna to gain something attention!!!