Willow Smith has earned praise aplenty for the eclectic sounds that have lined her critically acclaimed albums over the years, often blurring the lines between Rock, Pop, Electronica, Funk, and more.
But – as she learned after a recent visit to BBC Radio 1’s Live Lounge – that approach isn’t always universally welcomed.
View this post on Instagram
Still hot on the promo trail in support of her July-released album ‘The Thread,‘ Smith visited BBC Radio 1’s Live Lounge on Tuesday (November 17) to deliver a live showcase of the LP’s single ‘Unconditional‘ and – as is custom for guests of the show – a cover of another artist’s hit.
For the latter, Willow rendered a unique rendition of 2005’s ‘1 Thing’ by Amerie – a selection that didn’t sit right with some viewers.
“She sounds like she is singing through mosquito attacks,” said one commenter while another chimed in, “Her voice is more suited to an Alanis Morissette vibe or a Sarah Mclachlan – not really an Amerie.”
Other viewers were a little more forgiving.
“This song is not as easy as people think,” said one commente before another one added, “The key this song is sang/produced in is extremely difficult to sing live. Even Amerie struggles singing it in the recoded key. I give grace to anyone who attempts to sing it.”
The original clip racked up over 1 million views in a matter of hours and quickly spun into viral status, garnering many additional reactions like the aforementioned.
At writing, however, Amerie nor Smith has publicly reacted to the bashings.
Click here to see the full performance.





Some things just don’t need to be done…or attempted. Love you Willow but no
If you’re not familiar with her singing style then I can see why people are saying what they have about the performance. But this is how she approaches most of the songs on her albums. I thought she and her band did a nice job.
Are you kidding? She was patchy, pitchy and OUT OF KEY
Why would I be kidding?
If you’re not familiar with her singing style then I can see why people are saying what they have about the performance. But this is how she approaches most of the songs on her albums. I thought she and her band did a nice job