Dismissed! Beyonce Wins Courtroom Showdown After Plagiarism Allegation

Published: Friday 23rd Oct 2015 by Sam
beyonce-xo-case-thatgrapejuice

Songwriting chanteuse Beyonce has ample cause for celebration today.

A judge has ruled in her favor, quashing a plagiarism claim over her 2013 hit ‘XO.’

Details below…

Queen Bey’s artistic integrity reigned supreme following the judgment which dismissed the lawsuit filed by Ahmad Javon Lane.

Lane accused the 34-year-old of copying his song ‘XOXO,’ however a federal judge disagreed stating that the track were not the least bit similar musically or lyrically. He stressed that the themes were also different.

For example, Lane’s song was ruled to be raw and raunchy with “explicitly sexual” lyrics … such as describing himself as “horny” and loving every inch of someone.

Beyonce’s ‘XO,’ comparatively, was deemed tamer and laced with with love metaphors.

And that’s that!

{Source}

Your thoughts?

Posted under:

Comments 51

Please Post Your Comments & Reviews

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Lmfao_Hoe October 23, 2015

    5,4,3,2,1 here comes the shade, Stan wars, facts /unfamiliar bs, lies, Rihanna, Janet, Adele, other unnecessary bs to back up with or use as (un)credible resources – TMZ (the devil)

    • You tried October 23, 2015

      This fool said “she paid off the jury “????? Omg the type of ppl that be on here smh LETS PRAY!
      Clearly you all spend too much time on TGJ and less time seeking a higher education and mental help! BEY WINS can’t u c she was destined to WIN stop with this hating ish it’s getting boring and wayyy last old

  2. Suicide Blonde October 23, 2015

    Proves nothing, she’s still unoriginal, Madonna has won many lawsuits too, see 😉

    • King Mark111 /.\ October 23, 2015

      I caught that.

      • LB October 23, 2015

        Me too

      • Adele’s flawless cheek bones October 23, 2015

        Look at the three blind f*gs lol…
        1,One loves to snort coke, and is an insecure bottom,

        2,The other, a DL f//,

        3,While the lather, drinks c*/ like water, and is thirsty for d*/#

  3. 1mcluver October 23, 2015

    wait did Sam really just say “Songwriting chanteuse Beyonce”???
    lmaooo bish where

    • Drive by Comments October 23, 2015

      *In tears* Lol

  4. SipTheTruth October 23, 2015

    We all know she’s a thief. Paying off the jury ain’t gon’ change that

    • Anne October 23, 2015

      There was no jury. It was dismissed by the judge.

      • Flop free October 23, 2015

        So she paid off the judge? typical.

      • HailBeysus October 23, 2015

        Don’t bother Anne. It obviously just starts arguing when it doesn’t know the facts lmao

  5. Barb-wire October 23, 2015

    *waits for Stan wars*

    • Flop free October 23, 2015

      *waits for pink print to be certified*

  6. Slay_Hive October 23, 2015

    Of course. I said this! Beyonce stays winning and bums stay trying to make money off her name. #Queen

  7. Jiji October 23, 2015

    Songwriting chanteus??!! LOL illiterate heaux probably can’t spell her own name. Chanteuse.. Sam and TGJ stays on Mariah’s cl-it-oris.

  8. HailBeysus October 23, 2015

    HAHAHAHA SEETH AN HATE BISHES!!!! Y’ALL CAN STAY PRESSED TO FLOOR BECAUSE ADELE GOT Y’ALL N CHECK. THEN BEY GUNNA KEEP Y’ALL PRESSED WHETHER ITS HER POSTING on INSTAGRAM, POSING IN MAGS, BEING FEATURED ON TRACKS, WINNING LAWSUITS, MAKING HEADLINES FOR FAMILY DRAMA OR MAKING HEADLINES FOR ANYTHING UNTIL THE ALBUM DROPS!!! BEYONCE AIN’T LETTING UP!!!! SHE HERE TO STAY RELEVANT FOR ANOTHER 10YEARS YAAAASSSSS!!!!

    • HailBeysus October 23, 2015

      P.S TGJ y’all are behind i posted about this lawsuit win hours ago in the other post!! I also posted about ADELE SOARING TO NUMBER 1 on the ITUNES CHARTS!! BOTH ‘HELLO’ AND ’25’ IN THE US AND UK AND SEVERAL OTHER COUNTRIES ARE CURRENTLY ON TOP!!! WHEN Y’ALL MAKING THAT POST!?!?!

  9. christinastherealtalent October 23, 2015

    Describing Beyonce as a songwriting chaunteuse is my laugh of the day!

    • AnnaliseKeatingsNewWig October 23, 2015

      Describing Oinktina as anything other than a pig is more of a kii

  10. Yonce on your mouth October 23, 2015

    Of course it’s expected. Any hungry desperate fool who need two minutes of fame will come for Beyonce in whatever form. Just because the name is similar does not mean the song is. QueenBey remains unbotherd.

  11. .::Centurion::. October 23, 2015

    She’s still an unoriginal heaux, and besides, she has a pile of lawsuits she needs to get to.

  12. Bey Is Grown October 23, 2015

    #KingBey

  13. Fake Songwriting Credits October 23, 2015

    NEWS FLASH!!!!!! Units of Beyonce’s B’Day containing the song Still in love, will be retired from stores
    Beyonce infringed copyright, changed the name of the song and and put her name on the writing credits.
    So embarrassing, SONY ceased distribution of the album.

    • Flop free October 23, 2015

      More tea pleas

    • HailBeysus October 23, 2015

      Wrong Beyonce never to have wrote the . It was a cover. She simply put the song out before a deal was made. Here read for yourself dumbass hater
      explaining who she is to everyone she meets by saying “I did that You Gotta Be song – you know, the one off the official Princess Diana tribute album.” Because Beyonce and Des’ree have history.

      Firstly Des’ree is a very vocal supporter of animal rights group PETA – the same PETA that keeps spoiling Beyonce’s dinner. And secondly Des’ree is suing Beyonce for covering one of her old songs without getting the proper permission first. Metro reports:

      Charges have been filed in Manhattan Superior Court by Des’ree, alleging that the Dreamgirls star didn’t get permission to do her version of I’m Kissing You, which appeared on her most recent album. Des’ree… says in the suit that there was an initial attempt for a deal to be worked out, but that they wanted to change the title and film a music video, both of which were denied. As a result, the song was simply recorded and released, under the title Still In Love (Kissing You).

    • HailBeysus October 23, 2015

      Get your fuxking facts straight bish!!!

  14. blue October 23, 2015

    is this her first? Very telling that this was the first one that she let play out in court? What about the others she took care of outside the courtroom? Its like this time she knew she didnt steal…

    • LB October 23, 2015

      Or maybe she did a good job shredding the evidence

      • blue October 23, 2015

        bey too classy for that, she paid off the judge

  15. LB October 23, 2015

    Must be the first lawsuit she has won, or has not settled outside court.
    ,
    This proves absolutely nothing. Giselle still has her hands deep in the cookie jar.

  16. blue October 23, 2015

    jokes aside, that lawsuit was a joke, even a deaf navy member could tell there was no similarities.

  17. DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

    Bey doesn’t even steal music.. she steals concepts…

    Bey: Ain’t don’t nobody gone won’t us. To go to dey shows frank.

    Frank: why?

    Bey: cuz when gon take everything lol. When go meet everybody And say bey great show then steal it!

    Frank: everybody does that this

    Bey: yeah everybody does.

  18. shakira stan October 23, 2015

    Jezebel …am sure she committed every crime she was accused of but as always money over justice .

  19. DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

    Least fav song from 4: 1+1
    Least fav from self titled: XO
    Yet she performs them to death. Idk why bey didn’t release the better songs has singles & why she still marketting herself has an urban r&b hiphop artist when she’s already the nikki minaj of black artist. She should so another POP Album like Survivor & IAMSF… put the final nail in rihannas career while competting with the youngins adele & tswift.

    • shakira stan October 23, 2015

      There is a reason the hives keep winning the most stupid fan base .

  20. .::Centurion::. October 23, 2015

    “Bey doesn’t even steal music.. she steals concepts…”
    ____________________________________

    A mature insect. At least it admitted that Beyonce does steal. 😉

    • DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

      Tour should be a lot less worried about the queen Android more worried about ANTIpresperant. Cuz Adele isn’t showing any signs of mercy right about now.. Android bey is long overdue for another pop album. Its not safe for rih has long has the holy trinity(Bey Adele Tswift) steal owns a toilet.

  21. fatusankoh October 23, 2015

    Good for her I am so happy for her this haters think they can put in lies and get paid of some one hard work long live queen bey good luck and more success in all you do

  22. Janfiniti October 23, 2015

    SIMPLY, HER TEAM PAID THEM OFF. PAID OFF PAID OFF PAID OFF! EVERYONE IS GETTING PAID OFF THESE DAYS! THERE IS NO TRUST IN THE JUSTICE SYSTEM. EVERYONE HAS A PRICE.

  23. Tyler Makivelli October 23, 2015

    Thats right! Get with the winning team h*** #CaseClosed

  24. fatusankoh October 23, 2015

    Good for her I am so happy for her this haters think they can put in lies and get paid of some one hard work long live queen bey good luck and more success in all you do
    Why my com by not going in

  25. DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

    Centurion u should be a lot less worried about the queen and more worried about Antipresperant. The holy Trinity Adele Bey Android Tswift aren’t showing any signs of mercy. Things just aren’t safe has long has any of them still own a toliet

  26. DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

    ….Pfffft….

  27. DIABETES UNBOTHERED October 23, 2015

    Things aren’t safe for ANTIpresperant has long has the holy trinity adele bey And Tswift steal own a toilet.

  28. janvier October 23, 2015

    The navy & that suicide bottom are still mad I see………

  29. THE WORLD IS WAITING FOR ANTI!! October 23, 2015

    When was FlopO a hit? It didn’t even chart.

  30. Watermelondrea October 23, 2015

    Funny how people say someone like Lady Gaga always copying others but you never heard Gaga being dragged to the court. Madonna had thousand of lawsuit and now beyonce. That says a lot. Lol. Tired bish.

Recommended Posts
.. **