Jennifer Lopez Responds To Reports That She’s Replacing Mariah Carey On American Idol

Published: Monday 29th Apr 2013 by Sam

The net was set ablaze last week when reports that American Idol producers were planning a mid-season shake-up caught on like wildfire. Multiple sources claimed that the show’s creators were looking to oust Mariah Carey and replace her with rival and former judge on the show Jennifer Lopez. Carey’s only saving grace was said to be the legal action she threatened upon learning of the “coup”.

Drama, much?

Keen to establish if the story is fact or fiction, Extra put the question to Lopez directly in Los Angeles last night. Find out what she said below…


Hmm. As much as J.Lo’s suggestive silence indicates that there may be truth to the rumors, the cynic in us feels it’s one big (and clever) case of PR play. Or, worse for Carey, a calculated means to bump her off the panel by her nemesis.

Does anyone else find it suspicious that the story “breaks” the week Ms. Lopez announces her new single ‘Live It Up’? There are a few other interesting tidbits that make the whole episode rather convenient in its timing, namely..

* Fact that producers are beginning to think of next year’s panel (as they do every year at this time); reviewing what and who worked this year in comparison to prior seasons. With Mimi widely being panned for her credible, yet boring critique and with ratings on the wane, what time better than the present to launch a silent campaign for your old job?

* Mariah fired her well-known manager in 2008. He and his team have since gone on to orchestrate J.Lo’s comeback – including her initial Idol run, which helped light the spark under her mega-hit ‘On The Floor’. What’s more, under his guidance, the foundation was solidly set for Lopez’s first ever world tour. Hence, in knowing firsthand how important the Idol platform is for any artist, especially a 43-year-old diva, it feels like Team J.Lo are actively courting her former seat back.

* In the event she’s not pushing for a return to Idol, the story is simply great publicity for Lopez and a bad look for Mimi; which given that their new projects are set to be released during the same window makes the surfacing of such rumors seem more calculated than coincidence.

Of course, this is just my two cents, but in no way would any of the above be “bad” if true. It’s a) business and b) not like ol’ Mimi wouldn’t do the same. Remember this…

Classic.

Your thoughts?

Comments 135

Please Post Your Comments & Reviews

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Drew April 29, 2013

    ‘I don’t know her’ LOLOLOL! That never gets old!

    • Dev April 30, 2013

      LMAO! NEVER! Her expression didn’t even change.

  2. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    Mariah ain’t got time to worry about Jlo so Sam can keep reaching with that tired shade.

    • TruthSpeaker April 30, 2013

      Mimi doesn’t have the time because she’s too busy keeping up with her! lol

      1- Mimi to JLo alter-ego nickname branding
      2-twin babies
      3-Idol

      lol

      • veo99 April 30, 2013

        Hmmm!!! U forgot

        4 Mimi £500 million and J Lo less than half

        I guess Miss J needs to catch up!!!

  3. BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! April 29, 2013

    Why does J-ho have such skinny legs, with a fat ass???? EWww…MiMI looks great!

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      She doesn’t have skinny legs, it’s probably just in this pic. JLO looks great too. She just has that fierce superstar look that will never be duplicated.

  4. justin April 29, 2013

    UM Benny Medina was JLo’s manager first. And Mariah is washed up. She’s not cute. She needs to go sing at the apollo or something.

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      Mariah still has more money than JHO tho.
      Mariah still sold more records than JHO tho.
      Mariah still has more hits than JHO tho.
      Mariah is still more respected in the music industry than JHO tho.
      Mariah has influenced many of today’s artists unlike JHO tho.
      Mariah has more longevity than JHO tho.
      Mariah still got more money from idol than JHO tho.

      Mariah still doesn’t know who the f*** JHO is tho.
      ooops, Mariah wins again

      • justin April 29, 2013

        What happened to triumphant tho? (flop)
        What happened to Memoirs of an obese angel tho? (flop)
        What happened to E=McGriddle tho? (flop)
        What happened to her movie career tho? (flop)
        What happened to her cray ass getting naked in front of MTV camera?
        What happened to her last 7 singles? FLOP

        FLOP-RIAH

        SHE OLD . SHE TIRED. SHE HUNGRY. SHE IS QUEEN FLOP. THIS ISN’T 1990 ANYMORE. JLO IS TIMELESS!

      • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

        @FLOPTIN

        1)Triumphant- buzz single
        2)Memoirs of an imperfect angel – GOLD
        3)”E=MC2 – Platinum (1,289,00 in US)
        4)Mariah Carey is a musician she never tried to be Angelina Jolie or someone she was just experimenting and trying something different from what she’s use to. An besides, Mariah got great reviews from her role in Precious.
        5)When was she naked on MTV? please provide receipts to justify your foolish statements
        6)Mariah is the same age as JHO.

        The only thing you stated that was correct is that it’s not 1990 anymore.

        at the end of the day, Mariah still wins, and you remain pressed.

        anything else?

    • Fifi April 29, 2013

      K***, don’t try it… J-Ho has had way more flops than hits. Don’t even try it.

    • Common Sense April 29, 2013

      You seem mad. I know none of your faves will ever have a fraction of Mimi’s success but being bitter about it is not cute. Mariah can flop for the rest of time AND STILL be a legend because no one has done what she has done. Can the same be said about whoever your 3rd rate fave is?

      • justin April 30, 2013

        Triumphelephant:
        Australia Urban (ARIA)[68] 35
        Belgium (Ultratip Flanders)[69] 91
        Belgium (Ultratip Wallonia)[70] 35
        Belgium Urban (Flanders)[71] 49
        Croatia (HRT)[72] 38
        France (SNEP)[73] 135
        Germany (Deutsche Black Charts)[74] 4
        Global Dance Tracks (Billboard)[75] 16
        Japan (Japan Hot 100)[76] 48
        South Korea (Gaon Chart)[47] 3
        Spain (PROMUSICAE)[77] 36
        UK R&B Chart (Official Charts Company)[49] 29
        UK Singles Chart (Official Charts Company)[48] 144
        US Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles (Billboard)[46] 15
        US Hot Dance Club Songs (Billboard)[78] 1
        US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs (Billboard)[79] 46

  5. justin April 29, 2013

    Live It Up VS. Beautiful ! LET’S GO! TGJ Start a rival post!

  6. BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! April 29, 2013

    J-ho is really starting to look old…WHo said this drag-rican is youthful? H** look like Dora the explora grandma…

  7. BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! April 29, 2013

    Talent vs drag-rican wish i had vocals has been!

    • Fifi April 29, 2013

      YES !!!!

    • Christobal April 29, 2013

      WOW!!! Has been?!?!?! LMAO! When was the last time Mariah had a hit? JLo had the biggest hit of her career and one of the biggest singles of 2011! And was number 1 on Forbes list last year! HAHAHA Keep reaching!

      Not to mention making it on countess lists for hottest most beautiful woman in the music industry and in the world…. Where was Miss Piggy?

  8. justin April 29, 2013

    MARIAH WASHED UP.

  9. BEYSUS OVER JESUS April 29, 2013

    Mooriah Hairy fat ass.
    Mooriah and that damn
    blubber. Mooriah looks like
    Ms. Piggy, Nasty white b****.
    Them big ass gallon titty’s
    she got. B**** go get on a
    treadmill. She damage that
    with her fat albino ass. I
    hope Mooriah dies of heart
    failure lmfaoooo.

    • JESUS OVER BEYSUS April 30, 2013

      YOU ARE ONE LAME STUPID FOOLISH IDIOT…YOU WILL NEVER BE MARIAH. THE TOXINS FROM THE HATERADE IS EATING AWAY YOUR BRAIN LIKE TERMITE. CAREFUL WHAT YOU ATHEIST WISH FOR PEOPLE BECAUSE SOMETHING WORSE WILL OVERTAKE YOU UNEXPECTEDLY…BE GONE AND HAVE ALL THE SEATS AT STAPLES.

  10. Lady Caca April 29, 2013

    Love Me Some kat Figth!, But!, Jenni was a Better Judge Than Mariah ( Higgest paid to date )
    Can Wait!
    Live it Up VS Beautiful

  11. BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! April 29, 2013

    WHo f***** to get their first record deal??? J-HO needs to suck diddys d*** to kick start the damn flop of a career again! Kim kuntdashian is more relevant than this h**! Maybe she should shake her fat off the nearest cliff, because this h** is tired!

    • Christobal April 29, 2013

      She had a record deal before Diddy…. NEXT! Where is Mariah’s empire and movie career?

  12. Rosie April 29, 2013

    Both of them are irrelevant flops who can’t get a 3 million selling album in this day and age 🙂

    • BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! April 29, 2013

      No b**** that h** in your AVI is a f****** flop!!! I need a damn laugh * Watches SNL Lana the flop*

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        LOL! When was Moo’s last gold album? When was her last 3 million selling album. No one has cared about her since “We Belong Together.”

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      Mariah and JHO are still more popular than Lama Del whatever her name is.

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        …in the US. Lana is GLOBAL. Her tour will outgross J Low’s even though she just debuted on a major label and J H** has been out for how long? LOL!

    • Common Sense April 29, 2013

      And you’re basic fave is the flop who will always be remembered for that pathetic SNL performance.

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        Which only aired in the US. Can’t you f*** realize that Lana is GLOBAL? No one gave a s*** about the performance outside the US, which explains why most of her album sales come from outside the US and why BTD was critically acclaimed not including US critics.

    • chillin April 30, 2013

      Im sorry but whenever you break records and are considered legends…you will never be a flop..your legacy will live on forever..you young kids are so small minded

  13. RIHYAWNNA IS THE BIGGEST W**** SHE SLEPT WITH 1000. RIHOENNA IS A WASHED UP CRACKHEAD WHO EATS CRYSTAL METH AND SUCKS FIST BROWN D***. H***** INFECTED B**** HER GRANDMOTHER IS A NASTY DEAD MAMMAL. R****** ALSO HAS H***** AND A*** AND HAS A FAILING CAREER April 29, 2013

    Nobody is taking Mariah spot, J h** is irrelevant.

  14. RIHYAWNNA IS THE BIGGEST W**** SHE SLEPT WITH 1000. RIHOENNA IS A WASHED UP CRACKHEAD WHO EATS CRYSTAL METH AND SUCKS FIST BROWN D***. H***** INFECTED B**** HER GRANDMOTHER IS A NASTY DEAD MAMMAL. R****** ALSO HAS H***** AND A*** AND HAS A FAILING CAREER April 29, 2013

    omfg rihoenna’s v***** can stretch across the U.S. Her h***** is contagious.

  15. BEyonce fat ass drinks 3 packs of pepsi a day, and still can’t save Pepsi. She should use her bat wings and fly away! Her Career is over, but her old grandma ass is still trying it,! Maybe she should continue to Use that ugly @ss baby to keep her in the h April 29, 2013

    My name though..

  16. RIHYAWNNA IS THE BIGGEST W**** SHE SLEPT WITH 1000. RIHOENNA IS A WASHED UP CRACKHEAD WHO EATS CRYSTAL METH AND SUCKS FIST BROWN D***. H***** INFECTED B**** HER GRANDMOTHER IS A NASTY DEAD MAMMAL. R****** ALSO HAS H***** AND A*** AND HAS A FAILING CAREER April 29, 2013

    J.H** vs Mooriah vs Rihoenna vs Beyawnce. Who wins?

  17. Beyonce ugly @Ss baby should have been aborted,……I hope that ugly ass husband of her’s cheats on her, and knocks another h** up so this bish could lose her mind and overdose on a bunch of pills. That would be the day the world could actually breath! April 29, 2013

    My name though!

    • Queen Barb April 29, 2013

      That’s horrible

  18. Suicide Blonde April 29, 2013

    Has anyone catch J.Lo’s shade, “i don’t know, i don’t know”…it’s like she’s saying ,you might don’t know me but you sure will.

    Sometimes we are victims of our own words 🙂

    • Beyonce ugly @Ss baby should have been aborted,……I hope that ugly ass husband of her’s cheats on her, and knocks another h** up so this bish could lose her mind and overdose on a bunch of pills. That would be the day the world could actually breath! April 29, 2013

      If that was shade that s*** was weak as f***!

      • Fifi April 29, 2013

        Cause J-ho is weak.. Weak talent ….

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      Honey, no. I doubt that was shade. And that h** better not ever throw shade at the queen.

    • MC April 29, 2013

      Suicide, boo boo, J-Low is the last person to shade anyone. Stay cute boo boo and leave the attempted shade for those who know how to execute it 😉

      Stick to what you know best: whoring 😉

      I see you trying it on this page, I’m being nice to you for the moment being until my patience runs out.

      • Rihanna Legend (Lovebird) April 29, 2013

        J-Low??? Honey let’s not ok.

      • MC April 30, 2013

        Sis, please. Let’s not, ain’t nobody got time to be bickering with your delusional self. Mr. Beyonce’s weave 🙄

  19. Queen Barb April 29, 2013

    Mariah is such a lame ugly beastie looking b**** I can’t stand her j.lo is a fabulous gorgeous woman something Mariah will NEVER be.

  20. Christobal April 29, 2013

    Last I checked Benny Medina was JLo’s manager for her entire career except around when she first got married to Marc and then she rehired him and they reconciled after the babies were born!
    Also whoever thinks Mariah looks younger or better than JLo is delusional. JLo doesn’t use half as much airbrushing as Mariah and can pull any fashion look off, while Mariah wears the same tacky dresses over and over again. Plus JLo can still put girls half her age to shame. When was the last time anyone saw Mariah on a list of sexiest/most beautiful women????

    • DOSSOME April 29, 2013

      She’s in the bestselling female artists of all time list…at no.2…keep stanning for looks,let’s see how that works for you

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      Are you serious??? LOL How about the music??? You´re so lame

  21. Rosie April 29, 2013

    Triumphelephant:
    Australia Urban (ARIA)[68] 35
    Belgium (Ultratip Flanders)[69] 91
    Belgium (Ultratip Wallonia)[70] 35
    Belgium Urban (Flanders)[71] 49
    Croatia (HRT)[72] 38
    France (SNEP)[73] 135
    Germany (Deutsche Black Charts)[74] 4
    Global Dance Tracks (Billboard)[75] 16
    Japan (Japan Hot 100)[76] 48
    South Korea (Gaon Chart)[47] 3
    Spain (PROMUSICAE)[77] 36
    UK R&B Chart (Official Charts Company)[49] 29
    UK Singles Chart (Official Charts Company)[48] 144
    US Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles (Billboard)[46] 15
    US Hot Dance Club Songs (Billboard)[78] 1
    US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs (Billboard)[79] 46
    And Lana’s the flop? Death @ Moo only charting at urban in most of these countries.

    • Fifi April 29, 2013

      Lana will be long forgotten when Mariah is still making music. Mariah’s been in the business since 1990…. Lana will NEVER !!!!!

    • Hive April 29, 2013

      lmao i love u b****

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        Bringing up SNL again. Do you want me to bring up April 2013 receipts of her on tour where she sounds flawless?

  22. Suicide Blonde April 29, 2013

    Sam that is a bad pic of J.Lo, what happen, J.LO is one of the most sexiest/beautiful woman in the world, Mariah looks as usual in the pic.

    Ciao folks 🙂

  23. BEYSUS OVER JESUS April 29, 2013

    THE B**** WHO STOLE MY NAME TRIED IT!!!! LOOK AT MY PIC B****. HAHAHAHA TROLL.

    • Common Sense April 29, 2013

      That pic is everything. I knew it was a fake.

  24. RIHYAWNNA IS THE BIGGEST W**** SHE SLEPT WITH 1000. RIHOENNA IS A WASHED UP CRACKHEAD WHO EATS CRYSTAL METH AND SUCKS FIST BROWN D***. H***** INFECTED B**** HER GRANDMOTHER IS A NASTY DEAD MAMMAL. R****** ALSO HAS H***** AND A*** AND HAS A FAILING CAREER. April 29, 2013

    My name though 🙂

  25. Hive April 29, 2013

    Lmao Yaaaaaaaaaaaaas @Rosie READ THAT UGLY B**** MOORIAH!!!!!!!!! LAMBS STAY GETTING DRAGGED HONEY…

  26. Suicide Blonde April 29, 2013

    To everybody calling J.Lo a h**, she must be proud, she has made money for her ass alone, that’s something to be proud of, David Beckham is famous for take his clothes off, and one last thing EMINEM says hello.

    What you tryin’ to be my new wife, what you Mariah, fly through twice.

    • Common Sense April 29, 2013

      People call J.Lo a h** because she’s been married like 10 times. Every time she gets divorced and gets a new man almost immediately. This time it’s a guy half her age (not that there’s anything wrong with that).

      • Suicide Blonde April 29, 2013

        But so did Liz Taylor and many normal women.

    • DOSSOME April 30, 2013

      David Beckham is famous for playing soccer and damn @Suicide,your shade throwing skills are weak today,you know you wanna diss mariah,give it your best shot,don’t be scared,lol

  27. SUICIDE BLONDE April 29, 2013

    I got gonorrhea.

    • Suicide Blonde April 29, 2013

      You need the Kurt Cobain avi, trolls never learn.

      • Mark111 April 29, 2013

        That’s just sad! lol! I don’t agree with most of Blonde’s opinions, but to make a fake profile is just… just… weak.

  28. POW April 29, 2013

    LMAO at the rumors that American Idol is going to replace Mariah Carey with Jennifer Lopez. So, let me get this straight…You hired Nicki Minaj to judge a singing contest, and you’re bringing Jennifer Lopez back to judge a singing contest…and she will be replacing Mariah Carey as the judge…of a singing contest. Is the irony just completely lost on them?

  29. TheShade April 29, 2013

    So this rumor is getting quite a spotlight at the expense of someone who’s not riding the moment of the issue.

    J.Lo and American Idol Management are definitely taking this buzz to a level of blah, blaming others for the downfall of the show’s ratings where its clear that the contest is already a TIRED show. While the other one here is clearly taking advantage of the whole situation just to start a fiasco with her upcoming single.

    While the other sits on the judging panel, provides her critique to the hopefuls and say what she wants even if its against what the management wants her to say.
    She just recently released a teaser vid for her upcoming OFFICIAL single for her upcoming album but never used the AI platform to promote her stuff – Almost Home (but thats an OST).

    Seriously, the greediness of some people just to get the spotlight is FUC$ing ugly and i feel sorry for Mariah for not stepping up and clearing her side (although she already set for a GMA performance) because, as time has proven, she does not do these cheap move to gain popularity.

    But ladies are beautiful but their actions will show who has better decorum.

  30. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    my p**** is itching, I need some rash cream

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      Another imposter?
      LOL… you b****** are dumb as f***

  31. __________ April 29, 2013

    Ciara!

  32. ROSIE April 29, 2013

    who wants a blowjob?

  33. Rosie April 29, 2013

    SNL, SNL, SNL. Keep bringing that up because that’s all you have, at the end of the day Lana still outsold both of these old ass fading h***.

    • DOSSOME April 29, 2013

      The SNL Performance though,classic way to look stupid performing your own song…yes we’ll keep bringing it up

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        Of course you will when that’s your only receipt.
        3.5 million copies of Born To Die sold (AFTER SNL)
        Sold out tour (AFTER SNL)
        Versace, H&M, Jaguar endorsements (AFTER SNL)
        Headlining Lollapalooza (AFTER SNL)
        Mulberry bag (AFTER SNL)
        Multiple awards (AFTER SNL)
        First single from Great Gatsby soundtrack (AFTER SNL)
        Soo did SNL stop Lana from being one of the biggest forces in music today? No. And obviously no one even cares about that performance, it’s 2013, Lana’s winning, Moo’s flopping.

      • DOSSOME April 29, 2013

        is there anything to remember about LANA DEL REY aside from that SNL PERFORMANCE?her 1 stupid stan bragging about sales with 3.5 million..if her best sales only compare to Mariah’s worst,then she’s a FLOP…AGAIN,The SNL Performance though,lmao…was that part of the skit or she honestly can’t sing??

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        I mean how many times are you gonna mention SNL. Born to Die has outsold every MooMoo album since the one with WBT on it, and of course no one remembers the SNL performance because SNL is local, just like Mariah. Video Games is iconic and so are some of her music videos, especially outside the states. Deal.

  34. DOSSOME April 29, 2013

    5.6.2013,That is all i care about

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      I can´t wait. I think it´s going to be a nice and simple song. Unusual from Mariah

  35. Common Sense April 29, 2013

    Mimi is so above this annoying drama. She should take tranny Wendy’s advice and ditch idol. She’s too good for them.

  36. BEYONCE UGLY @SS BABY SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABORTED,……I HOPE THAT UGLY ASS HUSBAND OF HER’S CHEATS ON HER, AND KNOCKS ANOTHER H** UP SO THIS BISH COULD LOSE HER MIND AND OVERDOSE ON A BUNCH OF PILLS. THAT WOULD BE THE DAY THE WORLD COULD ACTUALLY BREATH! April 29, 2013

    I just lost my mom is a car wreck.

  37. Boy Gregory April 29, 2013

    The Emancipation of Mimi sold more than 12 million copies worldwide
    E=MC² sold 2.5 million copies worldwide
    Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel sold 2,000,000 copies worldwide
    and whats funny is Memoirs was her LOWEST selling album TO DATE. Most artist these days can’t even reach 500k. She is the most credible judge Idol has had.

    • Rosie April 29, 2013

      Lana’s album is nearing 4 million. Moo is a fat flop b****, deal.

    • truth(Nicki released 1,726 singles and 80 videos for re-up and still went platinum! Yea b****** i said it NNN WIT!! pops tongue) April 29, 2013

      album sales don’t make you a good judge though. fce mooriah cowry is now a stale and washed up flop

  38. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    DEAD @ ROSIE

    Mariah Carey:
    1)Artist of the decade (1990s)
    2)Artist of the millennium
    3)17 world music awards (most by any artist)
    4)only artist to have their first five singles hit #1 on billboard hot 100.
    5)18 #1 singles (most by any solo artist in history)
    6)two diamond albums
    7)5 grammys
    8)best selling overall artist of the 1990s
    9)Longest running #1 single of all time (One Sweet Day)
    10)song of the decade twice
    11)3rd best selling female artist of all time (worldwide and in the Us)
    12)12 platinum singles
    13)Best selling Holiday ringtone
    14)31 billboard music awards
    15)27 top ten singles (tied with Janet Jackson)
    16)recipient of the chopard diamond award in 2003
    17)best selling album of all time in Japan by a non-asian artist.
    18)$500 million net worth
    19)Second on Vh1 list of the “100 Greatest Women in Music” (2012)
    20)BMI icon for songwriting abilities. (2012)
    21)5 octave vocal range
    22)christina Aguilera, Ariana Grande, Beyonce, Kelly Rowland, Kelly Clarkson, Leona lewis, Rihanna, Britney Spears, Jordin Sparks, ect have all praised her and cited her as an influence.

    when will LAMA?

    • Rosie April 29, 2013

      Stopped @ #1, we are in 2013, move on like the rest of the world. Moo stans are as bad as than S****** stans when it comes to living in the past.

      • JESUS OVER BEYSUS April 30, 2013

        IDIOT SHE’S A LEGEND!!! THAT’S HISTORY THAT CANNOT BE CHANGED. LOVE YOU MARIAH!

  39. Rosie April 29, 2013

    That fake non-Gravatar ass moo stan tried it. My mouth is too clean and virginal.

  40. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    WHEN WILL LAMA?
    that b**** can never execute this level of vocal perfection. seamless transitions from one range to another. Vocal runs were properly done and not strained and over done and she perfectly sustained that last note.

    #winner

    • mr.m April 29, 2013

      Winner my a**!
      SO breathy and boring .. NO PASSION
      You tried it tho .. FLOPSTIC DIVA

      • JESUS OVER BEYSUS April 30, 2013

        DON’T CRITICIZE SOMETHING YOU CAN’T DO!!! YOU ARE THE FLOPSTIC DIVA…..ALL HAIL THE QUEEN!

        http://youtu.be/3yJADYvjCzM

  41. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    B**** your crusty ass stopped at #1 because you can’t handle all the stats and slayage.

  42. SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

    LOL, just watched that terrible Lama performance and completely rolled over and died. LOL, and b****** stay having the nerve to call Rih a goat?

  43. JER April 29, 2013

    They should have kept Jlo and just added Mariah to the panel. That way you would have two biggest types of female artists: the non-singer dancer and the vocalist. Jlo and Mimi are yin and yang

  44. theman April 29, 2013

    Sam u can sit down with the bs. U ain’t ever talk about idol like that until MC got on there, with your hating ashy lip a**. MC has some great critiques as far as singing is concerned. The ratings were still slopping even with JLo on it. Alot of people may not be watching because of Nicki Minaj. Don’t try to use MC as an scapegoat. Nicki has a very brash personality. That turns alot of people off. You know a show is a flop when they try to act as though it’s the judges fault for horrible viewership. Idol is tired. Constantly switching judges ain’t gonna cut it. Ratings weren’t that high when JLo was on either. Sam is always hating. He’s pathetic. JLo would use this cause is a marketing thing for her. Theres no replacing MC. Period…. By the way Sam trying to put that lil MC video in there at the end did not gain u any cool points. U are a certified hater. It’s ridiculous how u hate on MC for no apparent reason.. Idol is done period….

    • theman April 30, 2013

      Cause it is a marketing for her music.*

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      That´s true. They never cared about American Idol until… MARIAH CAREY was in. JLo was there for two years and they didn´t even care. As simple as that. And now they want to make JLo look better? B**** please. Not even lately, after Mariah being in the industry almost 25 years, J.Lo has been able to outsell Mariah. It´s as simple as that. Mariah is bigger and Mariah has talent

  45. Rosie April 29, 2013

    Mooiah stan stays obsessed with Lana because she knows even she is more relevant than her in 2013 :)Now go buy “Young & Beautiful” on iTunes.

    • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

      “Young & Beautiful”
      is that one of the many unknown songs of Lama?
      b**** please, i’ll never was money on that s***.

      • SLAYRIAH CAREY (SUPERIOR DIVA) April 29, 2013

        waste*

      • Rosie April 29, 2013

        But it’s currently charting better than any Moo single worldwide.
        But you’re right, I shouldn’t have asked you considering you probably didn’t even buy Triumphlop.

  46. DOSSOME April 29, 2013

    Hopefully,Mimi doesn’t return to this show next season…she’s in such a happy place in her life to get involved in s*** like this…anyway counting down to MAY 6TH 2013 when #BEAUTIFUL gets released.

  47. theman April 29, 2013

    The ratings were lagging*..

  48. mr.m April 29, 2013

    Man-iah is just a jealous W****!
    She hates J.Lo coz they’re almost the same age!
    AND Man-iah looks like J’s mom!! LMAO XD

  49. mr.m April 29, 2013

    +++ Maniah’s role in AI is A FLOPPPP
    The lost rating becoz of her flop old a**
    Ain’t nobody checking for her and for her flop
    Triumphant get em get em .. nuff said

    • MC April 30, 2013

      Yes, lets also talk about how The Voice had it’s biggest season right after the XTina left, Shakira being the best judge. Going to be a shame when ratings flop after Xtina returns 😆

      Mariah’s 18 million >>>>>>>>.. your faves.

  50. Rosie April 29, 2013

    Since the Moo stans keep bringing up SNL let’s discuss American Idol’s rating hiting all time lows every week since Moo signed on, Icki being more respected than her judging wise, AI getting it’s ass whooped by The Big Bang Theory every damn week, AI getting the same demo as New Girl, speaking of New Girl Zooey Deschanel being more relevant than Moo at this point and even her new album will probably outsell Memoirs of An Imperfect Cow.

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      B**** please why are you on this post??? You´re talking about Lana because…
      Keep it cute. I´m a Mariah stan but I like Lana, she is not a great singer but her voice is ok for the music she makes, she has her style and she´s a good songwriter. Kudos to Lana for trying it. But don´t come here to hate on a true great cos it´s pathetic

  51. truth(Nicki released 1,726 singles and 80 videos for re-up and still went platinum! Yea b****** i said it NNN WIT!! pops tongue) April 29, 2013

    Someone should put a muzzle on mooriah, every week she sounds like a stuttring idiot on AI. she also need to have some work done on her wrinkled up face, she also need to lay off the liquor because she looks 8 months pregnant every week it’s sad when nicki is styled better and sounds more coherent then you.

  52. DOSSOME April 29, 2013

    This DEL REY stan doesn’t get it,does he/it??We’ve got nothing to discuss after THAT SNL PERFORMANCE,that was enough to discredit anything she has ever achieved
    *plays TRIUMPHANT* as i wonder how a b**** would fly all the way to the US to mock her entire existence

  53. Rihanna Legend (Lovebird) April 29, 2013

    I love love love me some J.Lo, cannot wait for the new music. She always delivers on stage, she just tears the whole place down.

    Yassss for Mz Jenny from the block.

  54. Mark111 April 29, 2013

    I been saying that MC is a shitty judge. “But she can sing and sold this much and blah blah blah.” That’s cool, but it doesn’t mean she’s good in everything, for example, the b**** can’t dance to save her life. So J.lo IS better then her in something. Last I checked, dancing is just as much as a talent as singing. One more, J can act and is very big in Hollywood,must I bring up Glitter? I would to go a J.lo show over a lip singing MC show anythime (but I wont). J.lo checks more boxs then MC, like someone said up there, this isn’t 1990, she’s not that great anymore, BUT she’s well respected and that’s cool, but don’t be a diva when you’re not top dog anymore cause Bey is the baddest woman out and got everyone’s crown.

    • JESUS OVER BEYSUS April 30, 2013

      MARIAH IS A VOCALIST. DID SHE TELL ANYONE SHE LOVES TO DANCE. EVERYONE HAS THEIR SHINE AND REIGN. ONE DAY PEOPLE WILL LOOK BACK AT BEYONCE AND REMEMBER BEYONCE IN HER PRIME. YOU DONT SEE CELINE DION DANCING ALL OVER THE STAGE; SHE IS A VOCALIST AND ONE OF THE MOST RESPECTED ARTIST IN THE BUSINESS.

  55. J.LOvebird April 29, 2013

    I always wonder why the Mariah Carey fans are always coming for J.Lo? Why are you Mariah fans always so mad?

    I just genuinely want to know because I don’t hate Mariah fans, I only shaded her once because of one attention seeking Mariah fan.

  56. Joseline Hernandez *The Puerto Rican Princess* April 30, 2013

    J. Lo sings like a cat and hasn’t had a successful album since that song with Ja Rule. She’s a pretty shitty actress too. Mariah can’t sing anymore, but she’s still lightyears ahead of J. Lo. Send her ass back to the Bronx.

    • Christobal April 30, 2013

      ::cough cough:: On The Floor…. one of the highest selling singles of 2011 and her career… good try! And at least JLo can put on a show and dance her ass off to make up for her limited vocal ability.

      Mariah’s vocals are limited now, she has a backing track, and just stands there flailing her arms lmao! Great entertainment that is!

  57. DOSSOME April 30, 2013

    @LOVEBIRD
    Scroll this post and spot the Mariah fans attacking JLo…Personally i don’t use JLO but i respect what she has done for herself..This site always downplays and rubbishes Mariah’s achievements to the point people like ROSIE,with her fave who’s worth a mere $500,000 get the audacity to attack her…we get to deal with Nicki stans wishing Mariah to die and the Hive wishing death on her kids but since Sam wants those hits,he wouldn’t moderate the comments…SMFH,and now it’s Mariah fans doing the attacking according to you..

    • RICHANDBLACK11 April 30, 2013

      That’s a damn shame HIVE members wishing death on mimi Kids that’s HORRIBLE.

  58. Theman April 30, 2013

    U idiots are out of your damn mind. MC is the best vocalist period. She’s delivered quite a few great vocals recently. Go somewhere with all of that. Whose talking about glitter. Gotta do better than that. JLo’s musical/single success depends on idol. It was still failing with her on it. She won’t change anything.That show is dud. It’s funny how as soon as her single is about to be released, all of this foolishness comes up.. Pit Bull will make the song as he did before. Much props to him.

  59. Theman April 30, 2013

    Idol ain’t do nothing for Jlo but give her a hit single and a half. Idol keeps press around her, and puts money in her pockets. It’s basically her relevance to music. Then she’s signing to some flop label. Lol.. Idol really isn’t a big deal anymore. They hyped Nicki up, where’s the audience that she was supposed to bring? She got that money and that’s that.. A lot of people tuned out because of her.. This site knows better..

  60. Likica April 30, 2013

    No need to fight about who is a bigger musician. Mariah wins easily, all of us know that. But J. Lo is quite successful as a musician as well. To be honest she is an icon for me. If you are a guy, you cannot understand it. Her beauty, charisma, amazing dancing skills and cute personality make me respect her. She is such an inspiration to me. Her fashion is flawless! Mariah has an amazing voice that J. Lo lacks, but J. Lo has IT (I cannot even define it, it is simply there when you look at her) that Mariah misses. So stop arguing, both are great!

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      You made such a big mistake: JLo is not a musician hun 🙂

  61. RoyalKev April 30, 2013

    I’d love to see Jlo return to Idol. I love her, she was just a great judge with something constructive to say. I’m here for the music too! the Jenny from the Block vibe is just what she needs, I’m glad she’s returning to her roots. Mariah’s returning back to music and after Idol she will not be ignored once she drops. So, it’s a win win for everybody!

  62. just sayin’ April 30, 2013

    Not this silly fued again.
    The Lovers need not to fall into Sam trap and lambs need not to feed into the haters. I AM A LAMB ALL DAY BUT neither of these woman are flops people. STOP comparing these two. Rules to life, even winners lose. Meaning they both may have a few flop projects but their careers are not flops. Both woman have longevity for different reasons. Mariah for her music and voice & Jennifer for dancing, beauty, fashion, & movies. It is okay lambs that Mariah may not be on JLo level for movies or fashion but JLo is not on MC level of singing and making music, writing, and producing.
    It balances out to success for both in different categories

  63. eric April 30, 2013

    The AI producers fed Jennifer her every critique to assist them in manipulating last year’s competition. Mariah thinks for herself and comes across as MUCH more genuine and caring as an AI judge.

  64. hot mama April 30, 2013

    jenny is hot ..plus she is a way better judge on AI

  65. theman April 30, 2013

    JLo is a decent actress. Don’t get carried away. She’s more of a brand than anything else, not that theres anything wrong with that tho.

    • JOHNVIDAL April 30, 2013

      Another fact! Thanks

  66. Confused April 30, 2013

    Yes, Mariah is a far better singer and has much better songs, but Jennifer seems pretty intent on establishing herself as a huge touring star like Madonna. I think Jennifer’s concerts over the summer did quite well whereas Mariah has a hard time getting a crowd. Jennifer just needs to have tons and tons of better songs quickly so she has good material to tour. Love? was a good album but I had already heard half of the songs when it came out.

    That said, having Mariah and JLo both on idol at the same time would be insane. You would HAVE to see that.

  67. TeamBreezy April 30, 2013

    I bet you know her now dont u Mimi? lol

  68. Slay_Hive January 22, 2015

    ,,,

  69. Slay_Hive January 22, 2015

    Ii

  70. Slay_Hive January 22, 2015

    Kj

Recommended Posts
.. **